Affiliate Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links to products we recommend. If you click on these links and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend products and services we believe will add value to our readers. Read our full disclosure policy.

I Moved from Florida to Virginia and Saved $700/Month on Health Insurance (The State-by-State Truth Nobody Talks About)

Published: August 23, 2025 | 19 minute read | By DailySpark Team

Last year, I did something drastic that my Florida friends called insane: I moved my entire freelance business 800 miles north to Virginia just for health insurance. The result? My monthly premium dropped from $891 to $191. That's $8,400 per year back in my pocket, plus I got BETTER coverage with a lower deductible.

Here's the truth nobody wants to admit: Where you live might be the single biggest factor in your health insurance costs as a self-employed person. A freelancer in Massachusetts pays $485/month for a Silver plan. That same freelancer in West Virginia? $955/month. Same person, same income, same health conditions—nearly DOUBLE the cost.

After analyzing health insurance data from all 50 states plus DC, I've discovered which states are paradise for the self-employed and which are absolute nightmares. If you have any flexibility in where you live (hello, remote workers!), this information could save you $10,000+ per year.

The Shocking State-by-State Reality Check

Let me show you the brutal math that forced my move. Here's what a 40-year-old self-employed person making $50,000/year pays for health insurance in different states:

State Monthly Premium (Silver) Annual Premium Deductible Total Risk
Maryland (Best) $412 $4,944 $4,500 $9,444
Virginia $390 $4,680 $6,437 $11,117
Pennsylvania $511 $6,132 $5,050 $11,182
California $575 $6,900 $4,474 $11,374
Texas $588 $7,056 $5,000 $12,056
Florida $591 $7,092 $4,839 $11,931
Georgia $497 $5,964 $4,993 $10,957
West Virginia (Worst) $955 $11,460 $5,033 $16,493

The Geographic Penalty: Living in West Virginia vs Maryland costs you an extra $543/month ($6,516/year) for the SAME coverage. That's a $65,160 "location tax" over 10 years—enough to buy a house in some areas!

The Top 5 Best States for Self-Employed Health Insurance

Based on comprehensive analysis of premiums, deductibles, state programs, and market competition, here are the absolute best states for self-employed health insurance in 2025:

1. Massachusetts - The Gold Standard

Massachusetts isn't just good—it's in a league of its own. Here's why:

Massachusetts has been doing universal healthcare since 2006—before Obamacare existed. Their state-run marketplace, the Health Connector, is the model everyone else copies. If you're self-employed and can live anywhere, Massachusetts should be at the top of your list.

Real Success Story: "I moved my consulting business from Georgia to Boston. Yes, the cost of living is higher, but my health insurance went from $650/month with a $7,500 deductible to $480/month with a $2,000 deductible. The health savings alone offset the higher rent." - James K., Marketing Consultant

2. Hawaii - The Paradise Advantage

Hawaii's unique employer mandate predates the ACA by decades, creating an incredibly stable market:

3. New Hampshire - The Surprise Winner

You might not expect New Hampshire, but it's fantastic for the self-employed:

4. Rhode Island - Small State, Big Benefits

5. District of Columbia - The Capital Advantage

The Bottom 5 Worst States (And Why They're Devastating)

These states are crushing self-employed professionals with high costs and limited options:

1. Texas - The Coverage Gap Disaster (Rank 51)

Despite being business-friendly in other ways, Texas is the WORST state for self-employed health insurance:

The Texas Trap: If your freelance income drops below $15,060 (100% FPL), you fall into the "coverage gap"—too rich for Medicaid (which doesn't exist), too poor for subsidies. You literally cannot buy affordable insurance at any price.

2. Mississippi - Limited Options, High Costs (Rank 50)

3. Oklahoma - The Premium Shock State (Rank 49)

4. Georgia - The Confusing Marketplace (Rank 48)

5. Florida - The Subsidy Cliff State (Rank 47)

My former home state is terrible for the self-employed despite high enrollment:

Get Coverage That Works in Every State

Tired of your healthcare depending on your ZIP code? MyPhysicianPlan offers the same affordable rates whether you're in Massachusetts or Mississippi. No state penalties, no coverage gaps, just consistent healthcare nationwide.

Get Nationwide Coverage →

The Medicaid Expansion Factor: Why It Changes Everything

The single biggest predictor of whether a state is good or terrible for self-employed health insurance? Whether they expanded Medicaid. Here's the brutal truth:

Expansion States (38 states + DC) - The Safety Net

Non-Expansion States (12 states) - The Danger Zone

The 12 hold-out states: Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Mississippi, North Carolina, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Wisconsin, Wyoming

The Math: Non-expansion states have an average uninsured rate of 12.7% vs 5.3% in expansion states. Those uninsured people still get sick, still go to ERs, and those costs get passed to YOU through higher premiums.

State-Specific Programs That Save Thousands

Some states go above and beyond federal requirements with programs that dramatically reduce costs:

New York - Essential Plan (Game Changer)

If you make under $37,650 (250% FPL) in New York, you hit the jackpot:

This isn't Medicaid—it's a special state program that's basically free comprehensive insurance for lower-income workers. If you can control your income to stay under 250% FPL, New York becomes the best deal in America.

Connecticut - Covered Connecticut Program

California - State Subsidies

Washington & Colorado - Public Option Plans

Both states created "public option" plans that private insurers must offer:

My Real Story: The $8,400 Move from Florida to Virginia

Let me break down my actual numbers from moving my web design business from Jacksonville to Richmond:

Florida Reality (2023)

Virginia Reality (2024)

The Results: Saved $8,400/year on premiums alone. Deductible $4,000 lower. Better doctors, better hospitals. Yes, state income tax is higher, but I'm still ahead by $6,000+ annually. The move paid for itself in 4 months.

Tax Implications: The Hidden State Differences

Your state's tax structure affects your health insurance affordability in ways you might not expect:

States with No Income Tax (But Watch Out)

These states don't tax your income, which can help afford health insurance:

BUT: Most of these (except Washington) haven't expanded Medicaid, making insurance more expensive. The tax savings often don't offset the higher premiums.

The California Paradox

High taxes but excellent health programs:

The Sweet Spot States

Moderate taxes + good health programs:

State Insurance Market Competition Analysis

The number of insurers in your state directly affects your premiums and choices:

State # of Insurers Market Result Premium Impact
Florida 12 High competition Still expensive (no Medicaid expansion)
Virginia 10 Excellent options 20% below national average
Texas 8 Moderate competition High due to no expansion
California 11 Very competitive Varies widely by region
Wyoming 1 Monopoly 40% above national average
Alaska 1 Monopoly Highest in nation

The Monopoly Problem: In counties with only 1 insurer, premiums average 35% higher than counties with 4+ insurers. If your state has limited competition, you're paying a "monopoly tax" on your health insurance.

Stop Letting Your State Dictate Your Healthcare

Why should your health insurance cost double just because of your ZIP code? MyPhysicianPlan provides consistent, affordable coverage in all 50 states. Same price in Texas as Massachusetts. No state games, just healthcare that works.

Check Your Rate →

The 2026 Catastrophe: Which States Will Crash?

Here's what nobody's talking about: The enhanced ACA subsidies expire December 31, 2025. Starting in 2026, we go back to the old rules where anyone over 400% FPL ($60,240 for singles) gets ZERO subsidies.

States That Will Implode

These states are sitting on a time bomb because their entire market depends on federal subsidies:

  1. Florida: 4.7 million enrolled, 92% subsidized → Mass exodus coming
  2. Texas: 4 million enrolled, 89% subsidized → Disaster incoming
  3. North Carolina: 1.1 million enrolled, 91% subsidized → Market collapse likely
  4. Georgia: 1.3 million enrolled, 90% subsidized → Chaos predicted

States That Will Survive

States with their own programs and Medicaid expansion will weather the storm:

  1. Massachusetts: State programs continue regardless
  2. New York: Essential Plan unaffected
  3. California: State subsidies will cushion the blow
  4. Connecticut: Covered CT continues

The 2026 Strategy: If you're in a non-expansion state, start planning your exit NOW. The difference between states will go from significant to catastrophic when federal subsidies end.

Your State Selection Decision Framework

If you're location-independent, here's how to choose your state for optimal health insurance:

Step 1: Determine Your Priorities

  1. Premium cost: Most important for healthy individuals
  2. Network quality: Critical if you have health conditions
  3. Tax implications: Calculate total cost including state taxes
  4. Lifestyle factors: Climate, culture, proximity to family

Step 2: Calculate Your True Cost

Use this formula for each state:

Step 3: The Shortlist Strategy

For most self-employed people, focus on these states:

Step 4: Test Before Moving

  1. Use state marketplace website to get exact quotes
  2. Call insurers to verify network doctors
  3. Check if your specialists are in-network
  4. Research state-specific programs you might qualify for
  5. Consider doing a 3-month "test residency"

Get Healthcare Freedom in Any State

Moving states for health insurance shouldn't be necessary. MyPhysicianPlan offers the same transparent, affordable rates nationwide. Whether you're in the best state or the worst, your coverage stays consistent. No geographic penalties, no state politics—just healthcare that travels with you.

Get Coverage Anywhere →

State-Specific Resources and Marketplaces

Here's how to research your state or potential new state:

State-Based Marketplaces (Better Experience)

Federal Marketplace States

All others use HealthCare.gov (generally worse experience, shorter enrollment periods)

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is it legal to move states just for health insurance?

A: Absolutely! It's no different than moving for lower taxes or better schools. You just need to establish genuine residency (driver's license, voter registration, etc.).

Q: How long do I need to live in a state to get their insurance?

A: You can enroll as soon as you establish residency. Moving to a new state is a qualifying life event that opens a 60-day special enrollment period.

Q: What if I split time between states?

A: You can only have marketplace insurance in your primary residence state. Choose the state where you spend most of your time or where you want your healthcare based.

Q: Can I use Virginia doctors if I buy Virginia insurance but travel?

A: Yes, but check network coverage. Some plans have national networks, others are regional. Emergency care is covered anywhere.

Q: Should I wait for 2026 to see what happens with subsidies?

A: No! If you're in a bad state, move now while subsidies still exist. It's easier to relocate with affordable coverage than in crisis mode.

Your Action Plan: Stop Overpaying Based on Geography

Here's what to do this week:

If You're Location-Flexible:

  1. Calculate your current state's true cost (premiums + deductible + taxes)
  2. Compare with top 5 states using their marketplaces
  3. Factor in moving costs vs savings
  4. If savings exceed $5,000/year, seriously consider relocating

If You're Stuck in Your State:

  1. Maximize current state programs (research everything available)
  2. Consider establishing residency in a better state (even part-time)
  3. Look into alternatives like MyPhysicianPlan that ignore state lines
  4. Plan for 2026 subsidy cliff NOW

The Bottom Line: Your State Is Costing You a Fortune

Look, I get that moving states sounds extreme. But when I did the math—$8,400 per year in savings, $84,000 over a decade—it became a no-brainer. That's a kid's college fund. That's retirement security. That's freedom from financial stress.

The harsh reality is this: The American health insurance system punishes you based on your ZIP code. Someone in West Virginia pays double what someone in Maryland pays for worse coverage. Someone in Texas can fall into a coverage gap where they literally cannot buy insurance at any price. This is insane, but it's reality.

You have three choices:

  1. Accept it: Keep overpaying based on geography
  2. Fight it: Move to a better state (like I did)
  3. Bypass it: Use alternatives like MyPhysicianPlan that don't discriminate by state

Whatever you choose, don't ignore this. With the 2026 subsidy cliff approaching, the gap between good and bad states will become a chasm. Take action now while you still have options.

Your health insurance shouldn't depend on your ZIP code. But until the system changes, you need to work within it—or around it. The choice is yours.

Final Note: State insurance markets change annually. This article reflects 2025 data. Always verify current premiums, programs, and subsidies before making major decisions. Consider consulting with a licensed insurance broker familiar with your specific states of interest.